Skip to main content.

Referee's Report Form

Paediatric Anaesthesia

Referee's Report form

Please complete the following form and submit it by clicking on the Send Form button.

Reviewer Details

Name:

Number:

Email:

Due Date:

Manuscript Details

MS Number:

MS Title:

First Author:

To help us in reaching a decision concerning publication of this manuscript, please complete each of the following sections.

General Evaluation

Data support the conlusions	SatisfactoryUnsatisfactory
Statistics	SatisfactoryUnsatisfactory
Figures and tables	SatisfactoryUnsatisfactory
English syntax	SatisfactoryUnsatisfactory

Recommendation

Acceptable as is
Accept with minor revision not requiring further review
Accept with major revision requiring further review
Reject, but give the author a chance to resubmit (or more suitable for another journal)
Reject
Priority:	1(High) 2 3 4 5 (Low)
Originality:	1(High) 2 3 4 5 (Low)
Is there concern about possible violations of general principles for research involving animals and/or humans?	Yes No

Additional Comments for the Editor

Please use this space to write any confidential comments to the Editor

Manuscript Details

MS Number:

MS Title:

Authors:

Comments:

These are comments that will be sent to the author. Since the final decision regarding publication of the manuscript must be left to the Editors' discretion, they would be grateful if referees would not make definite statements regarding acceptance or rejection.

For your records, a copy of the Referee Report Form will be sent to your email address listed above.