Blackwell Publishing

Referee's Report Form

Immunology

Report form

Please complete the following form and submit it within TWO weeks of receiving the manuscript by clicking the Send Form button.

Confidential Comments for the Editors

(Please complete the keywords section, if you have never refereed for us before, or if your fields fo expertise have altered)

Manuscript Details

   

Scientific Merit 

1:Excellent
2:Very Good
3:Good - acceptable if space permits
4:Poor
5:Unacceptable

In addition please state if it is;

1:Acceptable as it stands
2:Accept with minor revision not requiring further review
3:Accept with major revision requiring further review
4:Suitable for another journal
5:Unacceptable

Additional Comments to Editor