Blackwell Publishing Online

Reviewer Details

Name:

Email:

Manuscript Details

Manuscript Number:

Manuscript Authors:

Manuscript Title:

Recommendation

This version is acceptable

Acceptable with revision, not requiring further refereeing

Invite submission of revised version and have it reassessed by referees

More suitable for another journal

Reject

Presentation

Is the English OK? Yes No

Is the paper unnecessarily long? Yes No

Are all the figures and tables necessary? Yes No

If no, please detail which could be omitted in the Comments for Authors.

Do the figures need improving? Yes No

Is expert statistical review required? Yes No

Additional comments for the Editor

Your comments will remain confidential.

Comments for Transmission to the Author(s)

Manuscript Number:

Manuscript Authors:

Manusscript Title:

These are comments that will be sent to the author. Since the final decision regarding publication of the manuscript must be left to the Editors' discretion, they would be grateful if referees would not make definite statements regarding acceptance or rejection.

A copy of the report will be sent to the email address you provided above.

Referee's Report Form