Skip to main content.

Referee's Report Form

Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures -
The International Journal

Report form

Please complete this form and press submit or send this PDF version of the form to the editor.

Reviewer Details

Date

Name*

Email*

Manuscript Details

Paper Number*

Title*

Questionnaire

1:Is the paper relevant to the scope of the journal? Yes No

2:Is the manuscript original, i.e. this would be the first publication of its main substance? Yes No

3:Is the title an accurate indication of the contents? Yes No

If not, your suggestions would be welcomed.

4:Is the abstract adequate? Yes No

5:Are the conclusions valid? Yes No

6:Are the explanations clear? Yes No

If not, please give details.

7:Is the length of the manuscript appropriate? Yes No

If not, please give details.

8:Are the figures clear? Yes No

If not, please give details.

9:Are the captions adequate? Yes No

If not, please give details.

10:Are the references up-to-date? Yes No

If not, please make recommendations.

11:Are the references relevant? Yes No

If not, please make recommendations.

General Assessment

	Excellent	Good	Fair	Poor
Originality
Technical quality
Contribution to the field
Organisation of material
Clarity of presentation
Grammar and spelling

Additional comments for the editor

Will remain confidential.

Report for Transmission to Author

Paper Number*

Title*

Preferred Amendments:

Essential Modifications:

Reasons for Rejection:

A copy of the report will be sent to the email address you provided above.

Referee's Report Form

Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures - The International Journal

Report form

Reviewer Details

Manuscript Details

Questionnaire

General Assessment

Additional comments for the editor

Report for Transmission to Author

Fatigue & Fracture of Engineering Materials & Structures -
The International Journal