Blackwell Publishing Online

Please complete the following form and either submit it over e-mail to the appropriate Editor clciking the Send Report button at the bottom of the form or print it and send it be mail to the appropriate Editor.

If you experience difficulties with submission, please send a completed copy of the form together with a separate note of the detailed comments to:

Mark D. E. Fellowes
School of Animal and Microbial Sciences
University of Reading,
PO Box 228,
Whiteknights,
Reading,
Berkshire,
RG6 6AJ,
U.K.

Email: ecol.ent@reading.ac.uk

Please select the appropriate Editor:

Dr M Fellowes

Dr R S Fritz

Dr F S Gilbert

Dr J K Hill

Dr S R Leather

Dr N J Mills

Dr Jens Rolff

Referee Details

Referee Name:

Referee Email:

Manuscript Details

MS Number:

MS Title:

First Author:

Date Recieved by Referee:

Overall Assessment

Acceptable with minor corrections

Acceptable with some revision by the author(s)

Reject

Not acceptable, but with major revision by the
author(s) can be considered as new submission

The following are intended for guidance only. Further comments may be
given below.

Please grade the paper using a five point scale, where 5 = of such high scientific merit, novelty and timeliness that urgent publication is merited, 3 = worthy of publication but not of such quality that urgent publication is required and 1 = flawed scientifically, repititious of other work or flawed technically.

Grade:

Content

Paper too slight altogetherYes No

Scientific content insufficientYes No

Facts not newYes No

Ideas not originalYes No

Data wrongly interpretedYes No

Statistical treatment inadequateYes No

Conflicting evidence is overlooked or ignored (please give references in 'additional comments' box below)Yes No

Presentation

Paper carelessly preparedYes No

Text poorly arrangedYes No

English poor. Can it be improved by editing?Yes No

Illustrations below standardYes No

References incomplete or badly preparedYes No

Additional Comments to the Editor - Confidential

These comments are confidential:

Comments for the Author

Please use the box below to specify any comments that will be sent to the author to help efficient revision and improvement of the manuscript. As well as commenting on the science and methodology please consider the following questions:

Are the title and abstract adequate?

Are all the illustrations and tables essential?

Could illustrations and tables be improved?

Could the paper benefit from rewriting, condensing or omitting certain passages?

MS Number:

MS Title:

First Author

Comments.

Please ensure that you print a copy of the form for your files before submission.

Referee's Report Form

Ecological Entomology

Report form